Coverage ledger
16 audited inputs. No inflated denominator.
This bounded review separates direct embodied-agent research, contextual material, operational records, and keyword collisions. The original scaffold contained no general-chatbot report; new primary-source research is identified separately from inherited work.
3direct
4contextual
6operational
3irrelevant
Document audit
| Readable input | Class | Decision | Representation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deep Research Brief: 3D-Powered AI Chatbots | direct | Owner-supplied original brief; defines the strict embodied-agent scope and requested deliverables. | A taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbotsThe embodied-agent stackThe economics of presenceEmbodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependencyEmbodied-agent market map |
| Character Current research edition | direct | Completed research synthesis created from the supplied 3D brief; its taxonomy, product map, stack, evidence, economics, safety, and roadmap are represented. | A taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbotsThe embodied-agent stackThe economics of presenceEmbodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependencyEmbodied-agent market map |
| Character Current research notes | direct | Documents comparable product and editorial research used to frame the embodied section. | The embodied-agent stackResearch room |
| Character Current asset manifest | operational | Provenance and rights record for local-preview source imagery; not editorial research evidence. | Research roomAbout this edition |
| 0028 site profile | operational | Authoritative mission, audience, tone, visual direction, required blocks, and null domain state. | Reader-facing pageAbout this editionGuide library |
| 0028 build scaffold readme | operational | Confirms the canonical folder was scaffold-only and supplied no substantive research. | Research room |
| Portfolio project memory | operational | Controls identity, source/date discipline, imagery review, no-deployment status, and workflow boundaries. | About this editionResearch room |
| Portfolio model routing | operational | Governs execution cost and delegation; not reader-facing evidence. | Not represented as editorial content |
| Research coverage ledger | operational | Supplied seven broad keyword matches for audit; explicitly marked inventory incomplete and denominator unknown. | Research coverage |
| Agentic coding research | contextual | Relevant only to bounded agent/tool design; not direct chatbot research. | Flows, retrieval, and agents are different toolsTools need permissions, not personality |
| AI advertising research | contextual | Customer and conversational marketing references inform use-case boundaries but do not establish chatbot performance. | What a chatbot actually is |
| AI products and productivity research | contextual | Broad product/agent context; used only for system-category framing. | Flows, retrieval, and agents are different tools |
| AI use field guide research | contextual | General prompting and workflow context supports tool and evaluation boundaries, not chatbot-specific claims. | Evaluate conversations before launchTools need permissions, not personality |
| Screen Method research | irrelevant | A keyword match on support; its film/visual-method subject is not substantive chatbot research. | Not represented as editorial content |
| Short-form content research | irrelevant | A keyword match on support; the source concerns short-form media, not conversational systems. | Not represented as editorial content |
| Writing and AI research | irrelevant | Contains isolated chatbot references but its publishing subject does not materially support this guide. | Not represented as editorial content |
Recovered 3D research, section by section
A mapped route is not automatically complete coverage. Each row below names the synthesis and its residual gap.
| Source section | Status | Public synthesis | Residual gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Market definition and categoriesOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | A taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbots — the inclusion testA taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbots — useful categoriesA taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbots — do not collapse adjacent fieldsDefines a realtime conversation-plus-embodiment inclusion test and separates adjacent categories. | No exhaustive market census is claimed. |
| 2. Leading products and platformsOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | Embodied-agent market mapThe embodied-agent stack — authoring and runtime are separateSource libraryPreserves all eight product and platform entries available in the recovered edition, with official links and explicit non-testing limits. | The broader hands-on scorecard requested by the brief was never present in the recovered research and remains future work. |
| 3. Creation tools and technology stackOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | The embodied-agent stack — seven coordinated layersThe embodied-agent stack — authoring and runtime are separateThe embodied-agent stack — time is the integration surfaceSeparates authoring, speech, dialogue, behavior, animation, runtime, and operations. | Exact vendor prices and hardware requirements require current procurement checks. |
| 4. Product experience and engagementOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | The embodied-agent stack — time is the integration surfaceThe economics of presence — prove the incremental valueConnects turn timing and embodied coordination to task evidence rather than visual novelty. | Long-term retention evidence remains thin; no universal uplift is claimed. |
| 5. Use cases and market opportunitiesOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | A taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbots — useful categoriesThe economics of presence — model five different businessesMaps service, training, companion, entertainment, brand, and spatial categories to different obligations. | No fabricated demand score or market-size ranking is supplied. |
| 6. Economics and business modelsOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | The economics of presence — separate fixed and variable costThe economics of presence — operator noteSeparates fixed character production from voice, inference, rendering, moderation, and support costs. | No vendor quote or universal break-even number is asserted. |
| 7. MonetizationOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | The economics of presence — model five different businessesThe economics of presence — monetization follows the buyerEmbodied-agent market mapPreserves the recovered consumer, creator, enterprise, event, and advertising guidance plus its five planning bands. | Marketplace, sponsorship, and virtual-goods benchmarks requested by the brief were not present in the recovered edition. |
| 8. Legal, ethical, and safetyOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | covered | Embodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependency — disclosure belongs in the experienceEmbodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependency — rights are a supply chainEmbodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependency — design against dependencyCovers disclosure, likeness rights, dependency design, age and crisis concerns, and explicit legal-review limits. | This is an editorial framework, not jurisdiction-specific legal advice. |
| 9. Website strategyOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | operational | Guide libraryResearch roomSource libraryThe architecture implements a searchable guide library, research room, and source index. | Rankings, affiliate plans, sponsorship products, and a public 90-day launch are intentionally not activated. |
| 10. Final deliverablesOriginal 3D-powered chatbot brief | partial | A taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbotsThe embodied-agent stackThe economics of presenceEmbodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependencyPublishes taxonomy, stack, economics, use-case, and safety synthesis as full guides. | A verified live directory, complete comparison tables, rankings, and vendor-specific financial models remain unresolved. |
| Thesis and category boundaryCharacter Current research edition | covered | A taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbots — the inclusion testPreserves the requirement that conversational state and embodied behavior form a responsive loop. | None beyond the stated non-exhaustive census. |
| Market map and directoryCharacter Current research edition | covered | Embodied-agent market mapA taxonomy of embodied and 3D chatbots — useful categoriesPreserves all eight recovered directory entries, differentiators, official links, and evolving-product caveats. | Current product verification and hands-on comparison remain future updates. |
| Stack and recommended orderCharacter Current research edition | covered | The embodied-agent stack — seven coordinated layersThe embodied-agent stack — time is the integration surfaceReframes the prior stack into seven coordinated layers with timing as the integration surface. | None at architecture level; implementation details remain product-specific. |
| Experience and evidenceCharacter Current research edition | covered | The economics of presence — prove the incremental valueRetains the evidence limit: embodiment can affect engagement, but human-likeness is not a universal trust or ROI proxy. | No new user study or longitudinal trial was performed. |
| EconomicsCharacter Current research edition | covered | The economics of presence — separate fixed and variable costThe economics of presence — operator notePreserves the variable-cost warning and replaces fragile sample numbers with a reusable unit model. | Current vendor pricing must be rechecked before budgeting. |
| Trust and safetyCharacter Current research edition | covered | Embodied safety: disclosure, likeness, and dependencyPreserves AI disclosure, consent, likeness, dependency, health, age, and moderation boundaries. | Country- and sector-specific legal review remains necessary. |
| 90-day roadmapCharacter Current research edition | contextual | Pilot one job before scaling the agentGeneralizes prove-the-job, prove-the-loop, prove-the-business into a bounded service pilot. | No public launch or fixed schedule is authorized. |
| Source listCharacter Current research edition | covered | Source libraryReader-facing source library links original documents and the guides that use them. | Fast-changing product pages require re-verification before publication. |